On Tuesday, September 16, at 3:56 AM, Whitestown Metropolitan Police Department
(WMPD) responded to reports of vehicle break-ins in the Walker Farms subdivision.
Officers quickly located and apprehended one of the suspects, and a perimeter was
established to locate a second individual. At 8:19 AM, the second suspect was
successfully taken into custody. This coordinated response involved multiple Boone
County law enforcement agencies and was timed to ensure the safety of residents during
school bus pickups.
The following individuals were arrested and are being held at the Boone County Jail
pending preliminary charges:
• Shawn St. Fleur (20/M) of Whitestown, IN: Theft of a Firearm (Level 5 Felony), Felon in
Possession of a Firearm (Level 5 Felony), Theft (Level 6 Felony), Unauthorized Entry of
a Motor Vehicle (A-Misdemeanor), Resisting Law Enforcement (A-Misdemeanor)
• Judas Toutoute (19/M) of Whitestown, IN: Theft (Level 6 Felony), Unauthorized Entry
of a Motor Vehicle (A-Misdemeanor), Resisting Law Enforcement (A-Misdemeanor)
Follow-up investigation stemming from this incident led investigators to believe that
St. Fleur and Toutoute are also responsible for previous unauthorized vehicle entries and
thefts that occurred in other Whitestown neighborhoods. This investigative work also led
to the identification and arrest of two additional suspects involved in an armed robbery
at the Holiday Inn Express on August 30, 2025.
The following individuals were arrested and are being held at the Boone County Jail
pending preliminary charges:
• Wilson L. Simeon (26/M) of Whitestown, IN: Robbery (Level 3 Felony), Theft (AMisdemeanor)
• Katie D. Christinson (32/F) of Whitestown, IN – Was not outright arrested: Theft (AMisdemeanor), False Reporting/False Informing (A-Misdemeanor)
We extend our sincere thanks to the
Boone County Sheriff’s Office, Zionsville Police Department, and the residents who reported suspicious activity. Your vigilance directly contributed to the successful resolution of these cases.
Captain John Jurkash Lieutenant, Public Information Officer
Darrick Deeter, Public Information Officer